May 19 – A Depew couple has been charged by New York State Police investigators with the theft of $50,000 in cash and unprepared food from a Middleport pub.
Juliet McCarthy, 38, and Steven McCarthy, 39, both of Depew, were charged this past week with corporate corruption (a “B” crime), second-degree grand larceny (C crime), third-degree grand larceny (D crime) and fifth-degree conspiracy, according to SP Lockport’s Bureau of Criminal Investigation
On April 24, SP Lockport troopers received a walk-in complaint from a representative of Pony’s Irish Pub, located at 23 Main St. in Middleport, regarding two former employees who allegedly stole from the business between 2020 and 2024. Investigation revealed that both McCarthys worked together to routinely steal money and unprepared food from Pony’s Irish Pub in the amount of more than $50,000.
Both suspects were treated without incident at SP Lockport and transferred to the Niagara County Sheriff’s Office pending arraignment.
